Starting for the first time since April 30, Spencer Turnbull exited Wednesday’s Phillies series finale in Detroit after three innings with right shoulder soreness.
It’s worrisome news for a team that began the week by placing Taijuan Walker on the 15-day injured list with a blister that has prevented him from gripping and throwing his splitter the way he needs to. Given the circumstances with Turnbull — his return to the rotation and his return to Detroit to face the only team he’d known before the Phillies – the shoulder had to be pretty sore. The Phillies have the best 1 through 4 in baseball but don’t have much starting pitching depth beyond their core four and the 5-6 of Walker and Turnbull. Most teams don’t.
Walker’s replacement on the active roster this week was lanky 25-year-old right-hander Michael Mercado, who was called up from Triple A after pitching to a 1.71 ERA in 47⅓ innings. Mercado made his big-league debut in the Phillies’ 8-1 win Monday, going 1-2-3 in the eighth inning with a strikeout. He flashed a 96-97 mph fastball, low-80s curveball and high-80s cutter. Mercado was stretched out to six innings and 91 pitches in his most recent start with Lehigh Valley. That was only eight days ago, so he would make sense for a spot start in place of Turnbull if Turnbull is unable to take the ball next time.
The Phillies could also skip the fifth spot in their rotation because they’re off Monday. The next time the No. 5 spot would be necessary is Saturday, July 6, at which point they might have more clarity with Turnbull or Walker.
If both Turnbull and Walker miss multiple starts, the Phillies don’t have many options beyond Mercado. Max Castillo and Kolby Allard are on the 40-man roster but haven’t pitched well at Triple A. Nor has Mick Abel, who has a 7.08 ERA and isn’t yet on the 40-man.
The Phillies entered Wednesday 25 games over .500 with a 7½-game cushion over the Braves in the NL East, but if they don’t get good news on Turnbull and Walker in the coming days, they may need to explore adding an inexpensive rental starter before the July 30 trade deadline (a la Michael Lorenzen a year ago). They won’t need a fifth starter in October but they’ll need one in the regular season to prevent their bullpen from being taxed unnecessarily.
The Phillies led the Tigers 3-1 when Turnbull exited and extended their lead to 5-1 by the end of the fifth inning. Brandon Marsh hit a two-run homer and two-run single to pace the offense.
